This place is so strange. So we were going out for a last minute birthday dinner. We went to Rigatony's first but it was so packed. An hour wait at least. We decided to go somewhere else instead. Marcello's is right across the street. We went there and it was DEAD. No other cars in the parking lot. That should have been a warning. We went in and I swear the guy at the door looked at us like he didn't know what we were doing there. I had to explain to him that we needed a table so we could eat. So beyond odd. He looked irritated but sat us down. Food was bland. Alfredo sauce tasted very watered down and their bread is like bread cake or something. Very different. WAY too expensive for bland food. It's a cute place but there's a reason it's so quiet. Oh, and some older lady (Assuming the owner) kept walking by and just staring at us. I'm thinking she was also wondering what we were doing there since by this point WE didn't know what we were doing there. Make sure to read ALL reviews. I'm a bit confused why all of the 1 stars are not recommended reviews. Kind of strange.