A bit torn about this review so I'll start with the bad first since it is a short list and may need to be highlighted as it's in direct conflict with my 5 star rating.
The bad:
Food - it's true what the other reviewers say that it's mediocre. My fish was super battery a tiny bit soggy. BUT but house made gravy is to die for (be careful as the server failed to mention it was an additional $2 but I was happy to pay for this little bit of pleasure that came in a very generous serving). What made up for the average food was their awesome dessert which came at such a reasonable price AND made in house too.
Service - ok it's not really a negative per se but all the tables in my area (including ours) must have been asked numerous times if so and so dish was theirs. Nope. So that was a bit of a mess as it didn't seem like they knew which table the orders belonged to.
The good:
I went with a very loud eclectic group of ladies who usually only see each other once a year. 5 of us all different age groups and different backgrounds. Honestly at first we thought our waitress was gonna hate us cuz one of our friends kept annoying her with some comments. But she kept it together.
I'm not sure if this is normal practice but when we told her we hadn't been here before - the manager came over to say hi not long after. I was certain we must have annoyed him too cuz we all talk so much. After our meal he personally brought over a brownie with ice cream for all of us to share! Honestly we were completely pleasantly surprised. It was to die for so we proceeded to order more more more. We got the creme brûlée and the cookies with ice cream. Incredible. Heave. Cookies were perfect. They were so accommodating as my friend and I shared the cookie dessert but couldn't agree on the ice cream flavour and voila the manager said we will get a scoop each.
He was really lovely. Stopped by to check in. We had a lot of banter. Ask him about maple. He knows A LOT about maple lol.
We ask for the bill and ... what? All the added dessert was also on the house ... I mean seriously? Hands down ... my friends and I agreed it was such a good going out experience we had since we don't really go out much. Especially today which was particularly crappy with extreme winds and power outage. Thanks Union!!! Now I must google where Schomberg is (inside joke! Yup. We are at that level now haha)