I really enjoy going to My Pie. This was my 4th visit and I'm always satisfied with my food. I love being able to add as many toppings as I want for the same price, along with choosing my crust and sauce.
The guys behind the counter are always very friendly. The only issue is, it's not a 2 minute process. A lot of their marketing around the restaurant and on their website boast about it taking 2 minutes, not accurate. If you order a salad along with your pie, it could take 10 minutes, no exaggeration. It's still fast considering, and I can still get it to go, but it's not 2 minutes.