They have some items that are good, some that are OK. The menu is your basic Americanized Italian restaurant. I frequently find the pasta to be over cooked which is a shame when italian places can't get that right. I will give them a big thumbs up for their breadsticks.
Overall the place might be a 4 star place if it wasnt for its reputation which is stellar. I just dont think the quality of the food matches a restaurant that people rave about.
Also, as a result of the reputation the wait, especially on weekends, can be quite long. They do not take reservations (and I dont think they do call ahead seating either), so expect to wait.
The decor is OK. It is an improvement over their old location though.