Don't get the prix fixe - go for the Cote de Boeuf!
Been here 3 times - cote de boeuf for 2 has consistently been juicy and tasty. The last time it was bit over salted. However, one of the better steaks in Toronto - almost as good as an Australian steak! :p Avoid the cheaper cuts of steak - they're no good.
I've had the onion soup (average), warm goats cheese salad (slightly better than average) ... pretty much everything else is average.
Most recently I had the tart tartin - it was below average, puff pastry was dry and burnt - and probably a few days old. Creme brûlée was better than average.
Atmosphere is great - quite noisy and service can be a little slow. However, the service has always been sincere and friendly so a little tardiness can be forgiven. Reasonably priced - $40/person.