I'm writing this from a conversation I had last night with a very good friend.
He took his girlfriend there for dinner after he had proposed to her earlier in the day. I have not been there since the place was called Don's Lighthouse Inn. The food and service was always excellent. His fiancee always wanted to try the place so he made reservations at my recommendation of what I thought was the same venue.
They both tell me they were disappointed. The food was....eh, mediocre at best. His lake perch was...well....just terrible. I'm not sure what she ordered but they both said one try was enough. .