I agree with Sarah's review from 2007 -- Tatman's is great! We hit a deer at 75 mph in Nebraska and got our minivan repaired just enough to get us home. Tatman's and our insurance company (State Farm, which was also great during this whole thing) worked together without us having to act as go-betweens. The repairs were finished a day later than they said they would be, but I'm not complaining about that at all -- the van is fixed up just like it was. They even detailed and washed the van inside and out!
The morning after we brought it home, the van began to shudder and the check engine light went on. When we brought it in on Monday they fixed it that day -- one of the spark plug wires had been bent and/or frayed and the plug wasn't firing. Since there was no way to tell if it was the work they'd done or the accident that caused it, they didn't charge us at all. Plus, since we park under a tree and there was bird crap all over the van, they washed it again -- and since it couldn't go through the power washer due to the new paint, they must have washed it by hand.