Coming from the Land of Indiana, it's hard for me to judge a donut without severe bias. (Because if you've never had Long's Donuts or Boyden's even, you need to plan a trip to Indianapolis yesterday.)
Prices were pretty average and the staff was friendly. The donuts are HUGE and everyone was pleased with all the kinds we purchased.
I like to base my donut judging off of glazed yeast donuts and custard with chocolate icing. The yeast donut was big and fluffy and delicious. It was my pick from the two!
The chocolate iced custard one could use some work. It needs a bit more flavor and density, but it wasn't bad at all!
Overall, it was a good trip. Definitely the best I've tried in the greater Cleveland area!!