We actually like NYPD and eat here once every few months. We split the Chelsea salad. It is very good and we usually order this. My husband ordered the sicilian pizza and the waitress suggested that it be cooked "crispy" because sometimes it comes out soggy with so many toppings and thick crust. Unfortunately, the bottom was burned somewhat.
The service was really good. Our waitress, Kaleigh, was very attentive and friendly.