Note that I am not a seafood person - but my husband has always wanted to try this place! I didn't order seafood but I will try to comment for both of our meals.
I was expecting it to be pretty tacky inside and I was pleasantly surprised that I didn't see any plastic lobsters or anchors on the wall! The decor was what I would think a captains cabin to look like - lots of wood accents and it was actually really nice. All the staff were dressed well in black pants and dress shirts as well.
We both ordered the four course feast which is only available Monday to Thursday and is $21.99 for soup, salad, main and a brownie with ice cream for dessert. You also get unlimited biscuits with this meal. It was a really great price for all the food.
I have to say I am SO IMPRESSED with how quickly the food came out. The starters didn't take any time at all plus as soon as we were done our starters our dinners were ready.
The staff were very friendly.
Our server (I believe her name was Dolly) was always right there to refill drinks and those amazing biscuits.
The starters were great. We both had Caesar salad which was similar to Panera bread's salad with real cheese.
I had the potato and bacon creamy soup which was very nice and my husband absolutely loved his clam chowder! So the starters were definitely really good.
The mains...
My husband ordered the garlic shrimp. It came with two skewers of shrimp which he said were awesome, he was surprised with how many they gave him. His came with rice as well as broccoli...
The broccoli was just normal broccoli but the rice, he said the rice tasted like microwave uncle bens. Granted he really only cared about the shrimp so he was happy!
Now I ordered the Cajun chicken Alfredo (I know... Chicken not seafood lol). It was decent... Normally this item is around $18. It definitely wasn't THAT good. It wasn't exactly restaurant quality pasta or chicken - it was something you could easily make at home.
The dessert was so good! It was a nice hot brownie with vanilla ice cream covered in chocolate and caramel sauce. The serving size was perfect and the fact that the brownie was hot with the cold ice cream was awesome.
Overall I would definitely go again - probably order the exact same thing as well because you can't beat that price for everything you get plus the experience was overall really good. I would give it a 4.5 if I could.