I will go ahead and echo everyone else with... best Manhattan in town! Definitely give it a try if you are a Manhattan or a bourbon fan.
The first time we visited, we only had drinks and dessert. Drinks are great! Aside from the A+ Manhattan, they really have quite a few innovative and classic cocktails. We were pretty impressed with their drink list. The bourbon and whiskey list left a bit to be desired, but I do understand the limitations with Ohio's arcane liquor laws.
On our second visit, we actually had dinner. I went with the shrimp burger. So good! What a fun play on a boring burger! Definitely recommend this for anyone who likes shrimp. All the food coming out of the kitchen looked so good and all the tables looked happy and enthusiastic about their food. The place had a happy and joyful vibe! What a fun place to spend a Saturday night.
They had around a half hour wait the night we visited (it was around 8:00) so plan accordingly.. But it was so worth it.