After reading a few articles and reviews about this place, I thought it was going to be a lot smaller than it actually turned out to be. There was a lot of bar seating and even a corner in the. Ack that seated about 4-5 people all around a volcano bowl (or Undertow's equivalent).
I had the Dutchmen's Demise. It was gorgeous and super delicious and refreshing. All the cocktails are made with a lot of care. I'm a fan of any tiki bar, but they don't have to be tacky and skimp on quality. This one is very professionally done.
The service was fast. Noise level turned up around 9pm (I'm writing this on a Thursday) but it was still very comfortable and we were able to still have a full conversation.
Overall I can't wait to go again!