This was my first time at Island Sushi and my first time checking out the newly remodeled Plaza. Things are definitely looking good!
My mom and I had lunch here today and it wasn't bad at all. This is definitely the only option for legitimate sushi in the downtown area and although it is overpriced (minus one star), the service is great and the fish was fresh and delicious.
We sat at the sushi bar ordered garlic edamame, which was steamed and tasted great. We decided to order a bunch of sashimi because I don't like to eat heavy lunches. We ordered about 18 pieces between us - super white tuna, yellowtail and tuna with spicy white sauce. All of the sashimi was VERY FRESH and prepared perfectly. The pieces were generously cut too, which I appreciate since I think the prices were a little more than what I'm used to.
Overall, if you're in the downtown area and want a quick sushi lunch - valet at Plaza and sit down at the sushi bar. It doesn't seem to ever get too crowded during lunch time, so take advantage! :)