We recently stayed at The Edgewater during our visit to Madison. On a trip a couple of months earlier, we stayed at the Hilton and I have to say The Edgewater is MUCH nicer. The hotel has been remodeled and it looks outstanding! The bathroom was the nicest, most spacious I've ever seen in a hotel. The decor is warm and contemporary. Room service meals leave something to be desired. I highly recommend this hotel but I recommend you get your food elsewhere.