My apologies for sounding like a broken record alongside the other reviews, but I'd give it 3 stars for the same reasons everyone else says:
Service is great. Attentive, knowledgeable, friendly servers make it a good experience.
Decor is sharp & clean.
The pizza is good, however when compared to other other pizza places around of the same caliber, this pizza comes out underneath. We had the Hawaiian and the Socrates Revenge. They were good, but nothing to go out of the way for.
The worst part is the price. When compared to pizza places of the same caliber, this place is overpriced by a long shot. If you feel you must try it, then try it. But you could save yourself a few bucks going down the street to pizza fire for basically the same taste and quality.