Pizza: The crust is very thin and the sauce has a delicious tang to it. We ordered two pizzas - one cheese and one Barberini. The cheese was fine - I mean it is a cheese pizza. The Barberini blew my mind. It is a whole mess of nontraditional ingredients that work together perfectly.
Dessert: There are two: a flight of ice cream sandwiches and a ginger cake. The ice cream sandwiches won't blow your mind, but they are delicious and fun. I mean, they are a FLIGHT of ice cream sandwiches. How could that not be awesome. The ginger cake is one warm mountain of buttery goodness. Consider sharing it because it is big and rich.
Atmosphere: Wonderful. It is a little loud, so it may not be a good place for an anniversary. It would also be hard for a group because the tables are small.
Service: Friendly and professional.
Reservations: No and it is a bit of a problem. The wait can easily be an hour and a half on the weekend. Tip: call ahead and get on the wait list when you get in the car.
Parking: Tough. There is only street parking and Willy Street can be a mess.
Credit Cards: Yes