After talking to the GM (and being told that what we experienced was an enigma) we decided to head back to liberty market and give it another try.
We went for a late lunch/early dinner. We decided to share the tower burger with bacon on it with a side of Caprese Pasta Salad. I should add that we share meals all the time. That way we don't have left overs to bring home and we don't over eat.
The burger with the garlic aioli was SOOO GOOD!! The pineapple salsa was also pretty great. I usually don't like that kind of topping but it was definitely an awesome additive to the burger.
The pasta salad was so fresh. It tasted like it was all picked out of the garden rift before it was made.
My only complaint is the amount of food you get for the price you are paying. We got a burger, the salad, and a fountain drink for $17. Usually that's right around what we pay for that but we leave full. Today we were both still hungry. If we got bigger portions, this restaurant would be 5+ stars. The chefs really know what they are doing when it comes to what they put in their food.
Definitely going back!! I have heard the salt river bars are to die for and I need to get my hands on one!