I was so super excited to try this place. We live in West Buckeye so we came out this way specifically for this restaurant. I had the Arthur Avenue and my husband had the Alfredo and bow tie pasta. The Arthur Avenue is only bread, mozzarella, basil, tomato and balsamic vinegar. Very simple sandwich. There wasn't much balsamic vinegar on it to really taste it. I had a side of potato salad. Nothing special. My husband had the Alfredo and besides being extremely greasey, he said it was only "alright".
Unfortunately since we ordered simple things and weren't impressed I don't think we will be going back.