I've been going here for a few years. Seems to be family run!
For breakfast, it's certainly amazing. The food is good quality, good amount, tasty. If you're just running in for a snack like a cookie or croissant, I believe they're some of the best on the street - and they're large! As far as lunch goes, they have an amazing burger as well.
The only reason I give a 4 star is because the coffee isn't that great. There's a few other spots on the street that make a really robust coffee and it does trump Gayley's. That said, this place is consistent and yummy and affordable. Big thumbs up!