Small little shop that can be easily missed if you're not looking for it, which might be a good thing since you'd be miserable if you knew what you missed out on.
The Gelato is the closest I've found in town to the one I grew up with in Italy. Consistency and taste are spot on.
They have plenty of flavors to try...but please bring back the Kahlua Banana!
Can get a bit pricey but you don't need the ColdStone Love it size to fulfill that Gelato craving.