I think I'm in the minority by rating this place 3-stars. I also feel like my friends will disown me once they find out because somehow it's becoming a tradition for them to go to Ahi Poke Bowl and then Fatty Daddy's. Don't ask - I'm not sure how it happened.
Anyway back to Fatty Daddy's! I've come here twice, and I feel like these are the moments when I wish a .5 star was possible. Yes, the fatty daddy cup ($9!!) has all the wonderful ingredients (up to two flavors of ice cream, two layers of macarons, and one toasted marshmallow) ...but in my opinion, the toasted marshmallow makes it hard to eat. Also, the macaron was a little crispier/harder the first time I went. However, it had the chewy consistency the second time. As far as the ice cream itself...I'm not a fan of all the cereal ones they have. With the cereal pieces in the ice cream, they seem stale/soggy when it's in my cup. I don't know. It just doesn't quite work for me.
Pluses of this place are the customer service and the loyalty points system. The guys and gal (I've only seen one so far) are always super friendly. You can try as many flavors as you want. They also have a loyalty program - for better or for worse - where you can earn scoops to a cup depending on how many points you have at your chosen time of redemption. So that's pretty nifty. These aspects are ones that makes me feel like this place is more of a 3.5 stars.