You ever really really really want to like a place but it doesn't measure up? I did with Aft and it didn't.
The portobello fries were great. Nothing BBQ about them but they tasted good.
The brisket was good but the saucy/mayo on the sandwich wasn't. Would have like to have is a a dinner plate option rather than a sandwich.
The sous vide steak sounded good but at the end of the day you just boiled a streak. This shouldn't be on any BBQ joints menu. You just don't do that to a steak.
We did like the hot sauce and peach BBQ sauce. Would have loved to take a bottle of each home.
The lack of sides also causes this joint to drop points. Where's the cornbread, mac n' cheese, beans and collard greens?