If I could give 6 stars, I would. Tasted 8 of their 10 beers in a sampler and really enjoyed all of them, which is rare. Highlights were the winter Saison (which was not very saison-like- more of a vanilla winter ale) and stout which had a nice smoky flavor. Food was above par for a brewery with good local flavor. I tried the perogies which were great as well as a fairly basic but good turkey, Brie, and cranberry sandwich. Staff was very friendly.The highlight (apart from the beer) was the amazing setting- an old Roman Catholic Church. I am not much for church tourism (as a Jewish girl) but this one is well worth a visit. Formal confessionals now sell merchandise. This place is a must on your visit to Pittsburgh breweries.