Hubby took me here on one of our very first dates. He's so cheesy, isn't he? :p
I ordered a slice of their signature White Pizza and have continued to order it ever since! It's New York Style meaning it's pretty thin, just how I like it... I'm talking about the pizza okay! It's also made with herbs and huge chunks of ricotta & mozzarella cheese. It's an amazing alternative to your standard pizza with red sauce.
What's also signature is their red cups serving fountain soda for $4! So pricy, but you do get free refills so it's tolerable. Sometimes when Hubby & I are really in the pizza mood, we will order an entire White Pie! This place turns us into total cheese heads.
Secret "Not So Secret" Pizza is located down a dark hallway on the 3rd floor of the Cosmo. Most of the time, the line goes out the hallway so you really can't miss it. You wouldn't want to, either. It's THAT good.