We went to Tutti Santi tonight *hoping* for some kick-butt Italian food. We're recent NYC transplants, so good food is on our minds.
Tutti Santi wasn't bad. The wine list was actually quite good. Calamari was eh, not great, but not bad. Our entrees were, again, not bad, but nothing to write (literally) home about.. and prices were, well they were NY prices.
Was it better than a chain restaurant? Hell yes! Was it worth double the price? Probably. Will I continue looking for a good Italian restaurant to meet my NY standards? Yup.