All right, here's my update since the current renovation has started...the pool is not done and I hope hope hope they renovate the tower rooms (specifically, the heating, the carpets and the furniture,) too, by the time it's all over in May. Service was great and everyone was super friendly. We won several small jackpots on the slots during our few days here, so we cannot and will not complain.
Some caveats:
1. The heat in our room didn't work - not cool when it's in the 30s.
2. The food is still average, but there are deals to be had ($2.99 breakfast at the Grand, $5.49 Subway combo, $6.99 breakfast buffet) so at least you can get by without spending a ton.
3. The Starbucks charges airport/NYC prices - two drinks and two scones set me back $18.
4. It's still super-smoky in the casino. Do not wear clothes you care about and be prepared to move when it gets to be too much.
We'll definitely be back as per usual. :)