I've probably been 20-30 times even though I moved away from Madison shortly after it opened. Every time I am back in town I go back.
Easily the best pizza in town. In fact one of best pizzas ever in my book - and I have had a few. Fresh ingredient and very tasty thin crusts. They bake it in a stone oven and you can watch if you want. Pretty fast and good selection. Always Grisham service.
Easily one of the best food places in Madison - and during my 8.5 years in town I went to tons of restaurants.