Mellow Mushroom has a perfectly casual, college-centered atmosphere. It's on Mill Avenue so it can get very busy with intoxicated college students. It's not a place for those who prefer quiet "fine" dining, that's for sure, but it's open late and is perfect for a midnight pizza binge (my specialty!).
But as for the food, it's pretty damn good. I especially enjoyed their Maui Wowie pizza- it certainly did the job in "wowing" me and my boyfriend! I'm usually not a Hawaii-style pizza fan but this pizza was superb. The Philosopher's Pie is also a safe choice, but is not nearly as good. Their appetizers didn't impress me as much; it was pretty standard food for a pizza place.
Despite their mostly standard, typical taste as far as food as concerned, this is definitely the restaurant to come to for a friendly, laid-back experience that'll satisfy any pizza craving. The menu has plenty of gems; just ask a few of the regulars. The staff is cool, the place is cool, and the pizza is piping hot. Mmm.
Seriously. Just take a bite of the Maui Wowie and you'll become as obsessed as I am.