4.5 solidly.
I don't know why people would knock down forget about it. This was one of my go-to restaurants in 2012 (I must have gone in there a solid dozen times) and they treated us like kings at each turn.
Great for special occasions, accommodating of big parties and walk-ins on the most part, wonderful menu and wine selection, and super friendly service. Trust me, it's damn near risk free.
I RECOMMEND: The Veal Quattro Formaggio
This grilled veal tenderloin with a spinach and a four cheese sauce is divine, and while it's served with vegetables & potatoes, I always ask for a alfredo pasta substitution and they have always catered to my whims :)
EXTRA TIP: Head waiter gives great wine pairing suggestions