I've been going to Casa D'Angelo for as long as I can remember. I really like the salad, although it is a little on the pricey side to add to a meal ($4). For those who like smaller amounts of dressing, be sure to ask for it on the side.
I used to not really love the restaurant as I seemed to order poorly (I frequently would order from the specials and would be disappointed). I have since been converted. If you stick to their main menu, it is pretty hard to go wrong. My husband likes their Chicken Parm, but I love their Chicken Palermo with Grandma's shells on the side. I've not eaten for the whole day so that I could eat it all in one sitting!
The interior is a bit outdated, but the service is always nice and attentive and it feels warm and cozy inside. The waiting area could use to be a few feet larger though. I've never been when people are essentially left waiting out the door for their table to open up