We are not alumni so we brought no nostalgia in to this visit. I guess we were expecting rather amazing ice cream being from the dairy state and the main college of that state and what we got was OK ice cream. It wasn't bad but not worth buying in bulk.
We did really like the cheese and bought some of that in bulk. My family's main dietary needs are ice cream and cheese so we definitely got our fill. Beware the crowds but worth a stop if close.