I guess it's four stars if you consider what neighbourhood you're in? I'm not sure. It was very standard food, standard service and I'd even venture to say less than standard ambience....so I'm a bit dumbfounded by the reviews.
Food: grilled calamari appetizer and caprese salad. Serving sizes were correct. The sauce on both was identical. A bit strange. Under salted/seasoned as well. Mains were linguini with shrimp, and pizza w proscutto and arugala. Points for offering parmesan cheese. The mains were very average, no complexity of flavours, the pasta (like, the actual linguini) had the same flavours as something I'd make out of a box at home. When the server opened our bottle of wine, she filled both our glasses to the top right off the bat--no swirling, no sniffing. Just here ya go.
If your'e going with your family, and you live in the neighbourhood, I guess this is a good option. Since I don't have a family, and I live far away - I won't be going back.