I'd give this place 3.5 stars. It's not good enough to get 4 stars, but not bad enough to get 3 stars. Pizza Libretto is known for its super yummy pizza, so I was disappointed to get a mushroom pizza with a nice crust, but which got progressively soggier toward the middle. The toppings were nicely seasoned, but a bit undercooked, which added to the gummy, undercooked taste. The calamari appetizer was much tastier, as was the arugula salad, although the latter was a bit small for the price. The wine was decent. The service was nice - our waitress was very accommodating and had no issues splitting our bill according to what we each ordered. I'd try this place again, but wouldn't be jumping to go back immediately.