Not really sure why this place has a bad Yelp rep.
The wings are not all that bad and are certainly a step up from the usual 'bar food' wings that Charlotte seems to be notorious for. I will say, if you are craving wings though, you might as well walk an extra 150 yards down the street to Lebowskis Grill because their wings are by far the best in Charlotte.
When we went here, we had wings, pizza, and beer. Originally a Picasso's Sports Cafe, Sutton House hasn't changed all that much and appears to have assumed the menu. It's a plus that they got all the Washington Redskins crap out of the back room! (Go Bears). :)
If you are wanting Pizza & Wing combo, I don't know of a better place in the Dilworth area. Not the best Pizza in Charlotte, or the best Wings in Charlotte, but rarely does one place do both well enough to credit.