They were not busy when I went so was able to get my pie in 10min. Ordered a pepperoni and holy cow the pizza was salty and oily. Crust did not have enough char for my taste, was a bit bland and had little chew - it had a fluffy soft texture that reminded me of Dominoes.
I don't know what the fuss is all about, but thats Toronto, everything is always overhyped by people with no taste. A great NY pizza should strike a fine balance between crust, sauce and cheese. This pizza was totally out of balance. The oil and saltiness totally overwhelmed everything else on the pie. Also, I wish they put more red sauce on it, I could barely taste it so I cannot comment on it. The saltiness could be specific to the type of pepperoni they used, so I may revise ratings the next time I am there and order a different pie. The high ratings this place has been getting lately must be fake news...Makers gets a 2.5 stars.