Years back I would have gave it 5 stars, but it hasn't really upgraded since then. The store still does have great t-shirts, and interesting items be the register. They still seem to be trying for the Goth style they went for years ago (and I can't recall too many people into that these days, but I could be wrong).
But, I can honestly say that Hot Topic still holds a place in my heart, and I feel it would be a loss if it were to close down. I really hope they try to upgrade, while keeping that Hot Topic darker charm that they always had (not Goth). They should also consider lowering the prices of their cd's.