Let me start off by saving the service was excellent, they even kept it old school and gave us a cocktail waitress along with our waiter. Which makes zero sense but I appreciate the sentiment. The decor is cool, you are underground but the place is clearly dated which I will overlook for now.
I'm banking at this point on the seafood being extraordinary, the underground gimmick can't possibly be what's keeping people coming back all these years... right
NOPE, the food is mediocre at best. I mean I'm not a sea food snob and I live in a land locked state BUT sand is never ok in your scallops. My lady had some shrimp deal and was equally as enthused with the blandness. Again the restaurant is pretty cool decor wise, the waitress and their sidekick cocktail server took care of us incredibly well.
BUT you can get better fish at a chain restaurant. So maybe go for a drink, feel like your on a boat in 1971 then go somewhere...anywhere else for a delicious dinner!