I would definitely recommend The Pizza Buffet over Cici's. I thought the pizza quality was much higher and the staff also made an effort to make a white pizza especially for me. I realize that white pizzas are not too common, but was really happy to have that made for me.
They also offered some chicken, salads, and sides to round out the meal. The food was fresh and tasty. The buffet itself was about the same as normal meal at a fast food place, so if you want to pig out and get some good food at the same time, The Pizza Buffet is the place to go.