OMG! This is definitely the best burger I have ever had. Hands down. I am from New York and have had my share of good burgers (see regular at Shake Shack), but Penguin far exceeded my expectations. I had the Tommy Boy, which is a burger with cheese chili and cole slaw. While oftentimes a burger described as such, would be gimicky and sloppy, this was put together with care, high quality ingredients and great proportionality. My girlfriend ordered the Penguin burger which had pimento (homemade) cheese and fried pickles. You could hear her mmmmmmmmhhhhhing reverberating throughout the bar.
Also, great live music.