Let's start out with I love the authentic, Wisconsin supper club atmosphere here. It has been around since the 1920's so I am not surprised. The wait staff was friendly but they have a tendency to forget about you. Once you get your drink, it doesn't matter as much. They pour a solid drink as the Old Fashioned my wife had was solid. The steak I had was not great. The flavor was there but it was full of tendons and this was a strip steak. Then again the price was there. I recommend getting a smaller steak. The filet was good but the one with the bourbon cream sauce was too sweet for my taste. The parmesan potato cake had the flavor and right idea but the execution wasn't there. It was so thick that it was a little cool in the middle. The veggies were forgettable too. The real reason to come here is the fried food. The fish fry and the fried cheese curds are the real McCoy. As good as any I've ever had.
Sure it's a mixed bag, but if you live in Stoughton or are visiting Lake Kegonsa, make a stop. The place has character and does some things very well. I would go back again.