Consistently great food! I'm here quite often and I never leave disappointed. Yes, it is a bit expensive, however look where you are. You pay for ambiance, not only food. We had pizza which was very large, a good value for the $17 I paid for it, as well as the papardelle which was very delicious.
Drink selection is good as well, the 'make your own' gin and tonic is a nice touch and makes you personalize a drink to what you like.
My one knock would be that the only meats they serve is what is on special. This is a very carb-heavy restaurant. If they mixed in a meat dish or two on the regular menu, it would be a perfect 5