When visiting family in Avon Lake we were always pressed to find really good pizza in the Avon Lake/Avon area that was nearly as good or on par with the best pizzas we were used to having in our native Youngstown area or anything on the East side of Cleveland or Little Italy. Also many chain pizza shops in the immediate area usually left us rather disappointed.
If Pizza Cutter is not at par with the best pizzas in NE Ohio it is close. I personally think that it is the best in the Avon Lake/Avon area and so does my sister's family who live right in Avon Lake. The pizzas are authentic with quality ingredients with a crust that is not too thick. Their wings are very good too.
Avoid all the chain pizzerias in the area and make Pizza Cutter your default pizza choice, you'll be glad you did.