Well deserved reputation.
I'm literally copying from someone else's review, regarding the Ham & Egg & Cheese on pumpernickel. "Very satisfying. I did think that the bagel was a bit large overall, and lacked that shiny chewy outer crusty situation that great bagels show off. I also thought that the pumpernickel flavor was muted as well."
I ordered the extra egg (60 cents) and extra cheese (60 cents). Total was just over 6 bucks. Without the extras the sandwich would be much too thin. As it was, I only ate 25% of the bagel/bread itself with 100% of the hameggcheese. Fine with me, as it was totally filling, hot (true to the restaurant's name) & savory.