We arrived at Melt with our hearts set on ordering the Tokyo Tuna (because it was featured on Diner, Drive-Ins, & Dives and I eat anything the Food Network tells me is good). Unfortunately, it was taken off the menu long ago (the episode is old). Instead, my boyfriend had the Lake Erie Monster (haddock fillet). I can appreciate their marrying 2 of my favorite foods (grilled cheese and fish & chips), but for $13.50 and a 45 minute wait (for takeout), we expected something a little more special. Our 2nd sandwich was the Parmageddon (pierogi grilled cheese). I obviously didn't have my head screwed on the right way because it didn't occur to me until after my food arrived that I just ordered bread sandwiched between two other slices of bread. It wasn't bad, but it is exactly what it sounds like--carbicide.
I did love the cute small park that's behind the restaurant. If you can't afford the time to wait for a table, the park is good place to scarf down the sandwich for which you'd wait 45 minutes.