I've only ever been here for breakfast - and now that I've moved to the neighborhood, I seem to never think of this place for some reason....but I think I'm going to have to change that.
This place serves probably THE BEST beef knish I've ever had! I never used to think of a knish as a breakfast food (I've always had it as an appetizer to a dinner) but an ex-boyfriend of mine turned me on to it and I've seen the light. The New Yorker Deli serves their knish with the gravy on the side, it keep it nice and crispy:) Their gravy is very yummy and really makes the knish sing.
Their twister bagels are the size of my face and are very fresh. They don't give you enough cream cheese though, so you will have to order more to cover both sides.
The place fills up pretty quickly as it's not that big, so get there early. They aren't open that late either, so just make sure you hit it before 4pm.
It's a great place to start your day of shopping in yorkville and and beyond. It's a little piece of New York in Toronto.