I personally feel that the "experience" at a restaurant has an influence on me as to my judgment on my meal. At Tutti Santi, the staff truly made my wife and I feel that they were genuinely glad to have us there and they enjoyed taking care of us. My wife ordered the gnocchi, not usually being a fan of gnocchi, they changed my opinion. We had a wonderful experience. Not only was the staff enjoyable, there were obviously several regulars, that was also a welcoming sight. We even met another couple whom we have made a date to meet again at Tutti's in a couple of weeks. A local neighborhood place with regulars is a good sign....
My only criticism is that the wait staff was a little too ambitious to remove plates. They were not trying to rush us, but felt as if i barely finished my last bite before the plate was whisked away. Personally, I believe servers should wait till all at the table are finished before removing plates unless requested by someone at the table. Also desert menu too "common". Nothing out of the ordinary, pretty much what you would expect as Italian "staples"