Guys who are looking to find a new salon/stylist and are ready to shell out some $$ I would recommend Capretti & Co. After experimenting with stylists and salons from Great Cuts, Super Cuts and the non-significant ones, I was hooked on to a more "fancy" salon in Boston. Since then my standards have risen and once I reached Pittsburgh, I found Capretti & Co to be close to home and with a couple of good reviews on Google.
Here I am filing the void on Yelp. This is definitely a fancy salon - they offer massages, manicures and pedicures in addition to hair treatments and cuts and a lot of their clientele are women. However, do not let this hold you back as they do cater to guys and some stylists are better than the others for men's haircuts. You can call and ask about the stylists and they will let you know who they recommend.
My first stylist was Jill, who was great and patiently listened to what I wanted and checked in with me multiple times to make sure I was happy with the progress.
The second time around, I decided to try Renee who I felt was more experienced (and I believe she is the owner). She also was attentive to what I wanted done with my hair and made sure she delivered.
Notable things about my experience at Capretti & Co have been the preciseness with which they cut your hair (to make sure both sides are equal length - i.e. attention to detail) and the focus they give to the client. Both times, I never felt that my stylist was rushing through the cut or that they were distracted.
The haircuts range from a 25-35 for guys depending on the stylist and include a shampoo along with the cut (and a head massage to begin with). They do use products that are gentle on the hair (as I was told).
For now, I have found a place that I can got o get my hair cut safely without worrying about repercussions later on, except on my wallet. I recommend Capretti & Co without a doubt.