I've been here a few times. I've tried a lot of their pizza which seems to be their specialty. I've had pasta there - not so good. For the 4 stars - it's all about the PIZZA! The crust is perfect and the toppings are fresh and they don't skimp. I've had a few salads there as well and they are pretty good too.
I've had their sangria 3 times - first time it was GREAT, the next two times it was so/so -- a bit too sweet.
Beef Carpaccio was really very good!
I'd really give it 3 1/2 stars but couldn't figure out the 1/2 star mark ... so factor that into my rating as well : )