I've been going to Il Padre's for a couple of years now, ever since I moved into the area - and I'm a huge fan of their pizza.
It might be because I'm so tired of the mediocre pizza you get from all the chains, that I was really able to enjoy the genuine attention and friendliness that the owner and his wife put into their pizzas.
The toppings are great, and they're always flexible when it comes to additions or substitutions. One time I was picking up a pizza with my girlfriend, and there was another couple in front of us who hadn't ordered yet. The man produced a can of corn from his pocket and asked whether or not the owner would mind adding it to their pizza. All weirdness related to carrying around a can of corn aside, the owner was happy to do it.
You should expect a longer than usual wait on Friday or Saturday nights, just because of the sheer volume, but the service is usually quite good.
The only complaint that I could possibly assess is that on some occasions, I've found the pizza to be a little salty - but other than that, as far as me and my family are concerned, Il Padre's is pretty much "Always Your Best Choice"