I've been to Montana Meat Company several times for the "Buy One Get One Free" (dine-in only) hamburger deal. With a decent selection of burgers (including kobe) at such a great price, they could taste like rhinoceros fart and they'd still be worth it! Luckily; they're all actually quite good (especially the kobe burgers).
If you are a cheapskate like myself and usually go to Montana for the hamburger deal, you probably aren't going to get an appetizer. But if you feel like living large, I highly recommend the lamb chops (I guarantee you'll want to lube yourself up with the honey basil sauce) and teriyaki chicken wings.
The major issue that I have with Montana Meat Company isn't the food or the service. The problem with Montana is that the place flat-out needs cleaning. Last time I visited, there was a dead roach inside the building in the entryway. The time before that, there were tortilla chips on my seat. Unless you like sitting underneath lamps that are layered with dust for some reason, I really have nothing good to say about Montana (the state OR the restaurant) in terms of cleanliness.
If a dirty restaurant with the heavy smell of cigarette smoke doesn't bother you, visit Montana Meat Company today before BJ's put them out of business.
PS - I'm in a good mood. This place should automatically get one star for being a New York Jets bar.